|
The Razor "Pluralitas non est ponenda sine necessitate" Summer 2003Plurality should not be posited without necessity. In other words, don't make things needlessly complicated. This principle gives precedence to simplicity: of two competing theories the simplest one is most likely correct. Since October 2001. "Extraordinary claims demand an extraordinary level of proof." |
|
|||||||||||||||
For reference and further analysis please visit these "new media" outlets:Remember 9-11 - Why we are here. Day By Day - Humor for the 21st Century Scrappleface - see above Instapundit Andrew Sullivan FrontPageMag.com USS Clueless Voice of the Commonwealth Useful Idiots Coldfury Right Thinking Silfay Hraka Ann Coulter Pirate-King Pejmanesque Causes Worth SupportingITPAA - Supporting American IT professionals Facts About Israel - Think you know them? Bet you don't. MEMRI NoIndoctrination.org - Fight for free speech on campus Sar-El - Volunteer in Israel and make a difference TroopAid |
Deeper Thoughts....
October 1, 2003We're baaack. And you thought we had given up the ghost, didn't you? Well, we've renewed the domain name. And we'll be moving to an active domain. PHPNuke is on the horizon, mwuhahahaha... Meanwhile, something to consider: RE: The Palestinians: Ariel Sharon should draw a map of the future Palestine that includes all the territory he can feasibly give away. Feasibly in his case means not having his government overthrown or him being shot. Next, he should announce the size of that land in square kilometers. Then he should add that for each Israeli casualty, he will subtract one square kilometer from that total. Wound an Israeli? Palestine=X-1. Machine gun a 7 month old baby? X-2. And so on. See you soon. - Nic Sept 11, 2003 |
|||||||||||||||
|
"We live in a country founded by cheats, murderers, rapists, thieVES and terrorists WHO captured, killed and enslaved millions of Africans. THEY ALSO killed more natives than the Nazis KILLED Jews. ALL THE WHILE the Catholic Church PROTECTS CHILD MOLESTING PRIESTS- God Bless America" |
What is it with extremists and bad English? I recall seeing Klansmen holding signs saying "Nigers go home" at a rally in Greensboro - and there weren't any citizens from that west African nation around. Recently much has been made in the press about the poor writing skills of young Americans. This is yet another example of the problem.
The purpose of this "sign" is to make an impression in order to convey a message. One way to do this would be to cover your naked skin with writing (see a discussion on naked protests here). Another way is to take a symbol and deface it in some way. The Cornell lads evidently chose this route - perhaps because their bodies aren't as attractive as the Dixie Chicks - or because it was chilly that day. Because the flag has white in it, and because white displays black ink better, they can then combine the desecration of a symbol with the message.
However in this case, the first criteria seems to have been to fill up all the white stripes in the flag with "the Message"? Why?
Perhaps they are Visual Arts majors who couldn't figure out how to balance the short message of say "America=Evil!" or "America sucks and so do we!" Or maybe they believed like children that more of a good thing is always better, so they decided to continue adding grievances without regard to the overall content of the sign. This of course is a blatant disregard for the writing dictum that one should never use three words when two will do.
That said, let's take a look at the messages:
|
Message #1: America was founded by bad people and therefore American institutions are evil. Message #2: The Catholic church protects bad priests. Because the Catholic Church is an institution within America, America is therefore responsible for controlling the Church. Message #3: (implicit) Being patriotic about America is wrong. |
According to author Stephen Jay Gould, the worst historical sin one makes is to judge our forebears by contemporary standards. Setting aside the fact that the vast majority of historians continue to recognize the positive contributions made by the Founding Fathers of the United States, the logic of the protesters is wrong. Good can come out of Evil acts - and does so all the time. The modern day integration of Europe, for example, is a direct consequence of Hitler's conquest of Europe. The opposite is also true: good can beget evil - hence the old saw "the road to hell is paved with good intentions" (and one which the current administration is no doubt concerned about in Iraq).
Secondly, the connection between the USA and the Catholic Church has got to be a filler. Even those who rode the short-bus to school yet still made it into Cornell through the "Affirmative Action for Absolute Morons" program must recognize that the US government has no control whatsoever over the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church is an international entity that frequently conflicts with the agenda of the American government. The US is no more responsible for pedophile priests than the Pope is the 2002 Farm Bill passed by Congress.
Finally, the students fail to recognize that we are, according to William James, imperfect beings living in an imperfect world - and the same can be said of the institutions these beings create. As such every modern nation state has a few genocides and atrocities in the closet. However that in no way justifies ignoring the atrocities of today - as these students seem to be arguing rather pathetically.
Germans have every right to speak out against inhumanity - even though Germans committed some of the most egregious acts of inhumanity ever seen on the planet. The Japanese are some of the most outspoken pacifists of today, yet were some of the most militaristic of nationalities just 58 years ago. History does not bind us by passing on the sins of the fathers to the sons. Thank god for that. I'm sure there's a whole heap of sins buried in the past along with the moldering bones of my alcoholic Irish ancestors. I simply don't want to know what those bog-dwelling bastards did to survive - but I'm sure it wasn't all pleasant, legal, and proud. Still, in fairness to them and their memories, I'm here and managed to breed....
True patriotism comes from pride in national accomplishments and shame in national mistakes. I can still wave the flag proudly while knowing about America's 19th century genocide against native Americans. Did the US shaft native Americans? You bet. Did America rebuild Europe and Japan after World War 2 without turning them into colonies? Uh-huh.
Instead of a clear message of dissent we get "We're a bunch of university morons who should spend less time writing on flags in dorm rooms and more time reading and writing on paper in classrooms." Do yourselves a favor and take remedial writing classes you freaking assholes...
...
A joke - given to me by <thunderclap of Doom>The Mother-in-law </thunderclap of Doom>
5 Surgeons
Five surgeons are discussing who makes the best patients to operate on. The first surgeon says, "I like to see accountants on my operating table, because when you open them up, everything inside is numbered." The second responds, "Yeah, but you should try electricians. Everything inside them is color-coded." The third surgeon says, "No, I really think librarians are the best; everything inside them is in alphabetical order."
The fourth surgeon chimes in: "You know, I like construction workers. They always understand when you have a few parts left over at the end and when the job takes longer than you said it would."
But the fifth surgeon, Dr. Morris Fishbein, shuts them all up when he observes: "The French are the easiest to operate on. There's no guts, no heart, no balls and no spine. Plus the head and ass are interchangeable."
Note: I've done a quick search of the net and found that the joke dates back to at least 1999, and has been directed at lawyers, politicians and engineers. Personally I think it works best with the French; I also like the nice touch of a Jew handing over the punch line.
Sitting outside contemplating the garden, as the scent of the lilac nearby fills the air. It's humid, and some butt-kicking storms are heading our way. The roses are lush and not yet victimized by aphids, black-spot and Japanese beetles (the Japanese call them "American Beetles" by the way). The color of the new leaves varies from plant to plant, from pale yellow to crimson. May is the month for roses. The foliage is almost as pretty as the first blooms, when the garden turns into a daytime fireworks show making its upkeep worthwhile the remaining 11 months of the year.
While puttering around I found a bag of Spider flower seeds dated "Summer '01". Spider flowers (Cleome) are like the Americans of the garden. They sprout up in places where they aren't always wanted and often threaten to take over. They are showy, borderline gaudy with their fat balls of blooms. They also smell rather pungent. But when everything else is wilting under the summer sun, they keep blooming and don't stop until the plants are buried under the snow. I've always liked them and was happy to find the bag at this particular time when the garden is still being planted.
The seeds had been collected in the days after Sept 11, 2001 when the sky above our house was empty of anything - clouds and oddest of all, airliners. Honestly, I don't remember much about the days immediately after September 11. The pall over the New York Skyline. Sounds of F-16s patrolling overhead in the morning. A sky so blue that it almost hurts to remember it.
Americans in the garden...
When everything falls apart, when illusions that you've held for years crumble, when things you've taken for granted suddenly are gone, one is left with the Zen command to "chop wood, carry water". For me that meant tending the Spider plants - pulling their long seed pods which split between my fingers and released their tiny brown seeds. Chop wood carry water. I placed the seeds into a baggie, labeled them, and then stowed them away.
Last year the Spider flowers appeared in my garden as they usually did, but were shredded by beetle. For the first year in many, none made it to the point where they went to seed - and so my garden this year is missing the carpet of green, club-shaped petals as the Spider flowers race with each other to the sky.
So I cleared part of the garden known as the "hospital" - a section reserved for ailing plants - and took fistfuls of the seeds and scattered them. A world without Americans would be a dull world, and my garden is a much sadder place without the Spider flowers competing with the fragile English roses and Japanese maples for attention. Spider flowers are tough - last year notwithstanding. They are often hated by formal gardeners for their uncontrolled appearance and pungent odor. But honestly, I hate formal gardens and look askance at people who don't.
I raked in the seeds and then watered the garden, priming the earth for the rain.
Appy-polly-logies for light posting while life is consumed with trying to leave the ranks of the unemployed. However this Media Echo must be commented upon. Read it before continuing...
All done? Good. If this is true, then it could be a hit below the waterline for US-France relations. This journal is devoted to Absolute Truth - and currently there has been no corroboration from other sources of this article. The unfortunate thing is that it fits a pattern of behavior that has been established by the French over the Iraq Issue. As such it is difficult to not believe it.
If true, why? What has the USA done to elicit such behavior? Are the French people and government "different" then the rest of us? Do they not respect our shared culture, values and history? France was with the USA at the time that it was forged. France protected the USA when it was still in its infancy and could easily have been recaptured by the British. It guided American relations with Europe during the 19th Century. While much has been said about how much France owes the USA for "saving" it in the 20th century, very little has been mentioned about how France was there for the USA like a big brother during the 18th and 19th centuries. Without French assistance during the first hundred years of the Republic, America would not have survived.
Neo-cons need to be reminded of this before they bitch-slap the French.
So why? Why have the French betrayed America? On Sept. 11, only one French national died but three months later Richard Reid attempted to blow up American Airlines flight 63 from Paris to Miami. Had he been successful 197 passengers and crew would have died, and the number of dead French would have been much higher.
Why can't the French understand that they are viewed as infidels in the eyes of Muslim extremists just as Americans are, and that these forces cannot be pacified? America attacks its enemies and becomes safer for it. France collaborates with its enemies and increases the likelihood of attack against it.
France's betrayal of America will not result in Americans planting car bombs in Paris or slamming airliners into Parisian skyscrapers. The French really have nothing to fear from America beyond the loss of our friendship and respect. But the French have lost something more important than that: they have lost their dignity.
Okay I'm going to do something I swore I wouldn't do: admit in this journal that I recently became unemployed. Yes, my faith in the free market is being tested as my job was sent to India by a multinational bank whose CEO made $13 million while the stock took a 65% hit. So far I have applied to no less than 85 positions in my area and gotten a handful of nibbles but no bites. 12 years ago I swore that I would never get into IT because it would one day have too many people chasing too few jobs. Six years later I went against my oath and threw myself into the IT field. I was able to whether two years of the downturn, but alas, eventually fell victim to it.
I'm admitting this here because it helps explain the light posting. It's hard to think about anything when one is stuck at home, sending out resumes listening to commercials for refinancing on Fox News. But I'm not going to whine.
Just one question: Has anyone ever been hired by submitting a resume to one of the resume databanks used by large corporations? if you know.
I had to change the bumpersticker on the car yesterday. "Free Iraq" seemed so dated now, and besides could be misinterpreted as a call for the end of the so-called American "occupation" of Iraq (as if what the country needed was more non-occupation like Mogadishu...) And since people in my part of the country haven't removed their "War is not the answer" and "No to war" stickers, I decided that I needed to counter their yuppie naiveté with some of my own yuppie neo-radicalism. So should you be driving around the streets of Portland and see a green Toyota Landcruiser with tinted windows and a sticker that says "Torture? Genocide? War IS the Answer sometimes..." be sure to honk. Don't do anything else unless your windows are bullet resistant ;)
In three weeks America and its allies drained a nasty boil on the butt of civilization. In three weeks the rape rooms were permanently closed, Uday's chipper shredders silenced forever, and the children freed from the "children's prison". Kuwait doesn't have to worry about becoming the 19th province of Iraq again, and Israel doesn't have to worry about chemical-tipped scud missiles landing on their soil. Families of homicide-bombers will no longer be paid with money that would be better spent feeding Iraqis; Iraqi exiles will no longer have to look over their shoulders. The marshes of southern Iraq will no longer be drained and most likely will be restored. Where there was fear for the present there is now hope for the future.
All this has been accomplished with no thanks to any of the following:
Susan-Tim-Sarandon-Robbins acting unit
College-dropout Michael Moore
The Dixie Chicks
Martin "Lookat Me! I'm Jesus!" Sheen
Pope "I'm not dead" John Paul II
Madonna
France
Belgium
Germany
Russia
Canada
Mexico
Syria
"The (mythical) Arab Street"
Al-jazeera
International ANSWER ("I'll take 'Bored & Stupid Rich Kids for $100, Alex")
BBC (Pravda on the Thames)
CNN
Take a look at those names and don't forget them. I sure won't - and neither will 23,000,000 Iraqis.
Before Newt Gingrich took a shot at Colin Powell at the American Enterprise Institute last week, he stated that he believed one problem with Americans is that we think of ourselves as "happy hamsters" when the rest of the world thinks of us as a large elephant in the living room whose every movement threatens to break the family heirlooms.
How Americans see themselves. |
How the world sees Americans. |
I thought that was a pretty astute observation, especially since it gives me the opportunity to put a picture of Hamtaro on this site.
Having spent the better part of my adulthood abroad, I have to agree. When an American travels, s/he suddenly becomes a representative of everything from the LA Race Riots to Slavery to Baseball. Americans tend to think that everyone in the world knows that we're just a big nation full of "happy hamsters" - but the world recognizes that "happy hamsters" don't take out a Middle Eastern country in 3 weeks of fighting. Hamsters don't have the Marine Corps nor Special Ops units.
The world is starting to fear us - and that is a good thing. One of the reasons we endured the nightmare of September 11, 2001 is that our enemies didn't fear us anymore. Osama Bin Laden and his supporters believed that we were hamsters, that we had grown soft, fat and furry. Since Bin Laden and his ilk live in the 12th Century, they failed to recognize the lesson the Japanese learned 60 years ago. They too had believed that Americans were hamsters incapable of defending themselves. As a result of that error we erased Japan and rebuilt it into the peaceful place that it is today. Bin Laden and his followers met the same fate as the Japanese military junta that engineered the attack on America.
What our supposed "allies" must understand is that while we may not be the hamsters that we think we are, being hamsters in a world of terror and failed Arab Culture isn't feasible. While Hamtaro may not have to worry about becoming a cat-treat, he would if he turned up in my household.
It is in the world's best interest that we continue to see ourselves in the USA as hamsters, but it isn't in our own interest - nor the world's. One fifth of the world's population lives in a culture that cannot modernize, and so thrashes about looking for scapegoats and conspiracies. The only solution is for the USA to erase this culture and allow a new Arab culture to arise - one that is independent from the USA yet able to show Arabs that they can succeed without looking back or blowing up Americans and Jews.
Okay, we'll admit it: we miss "Baghdad Bob" AKA Mohammed Saeed al-Sahaf, (former) Iraqi Minister of Information. Yes we know that he worked for a bloodthirsty boss, and narc'ed on his brother-in-law, but you got a like a guy who is able to say the following with heart:

So thanks to Mrs. Machiavelli's insomnia, we found this website and recommend it to all who miss Baghdad Bob: WeLovetheIraqiInformationMinister.com.
So "Let the American infidels bask in their illusion" and check out the site for your Baghdad Bob fix today.
Read this now. It is proof that there remain French people who espouse such human rights as liberty and freedom. Yes, after the tears shed over Saddam and the desecration of the cemetery reported below I had thought that all decent French people were dead. Unfortunately there may not be enough of them to save France, but at least it will not be a complete rout.
Mrs. Machiavelli noted this morning the inverse relationship between patriotism and privilege in popular culture. For example, the mother of rescued POW Shoshana Johnson appeared in an interview today wearing a sweater bearing the American flag. Nearly every scene of rescued POW Jessica Lynch's family home shows the American flag fluttering on the flag pole above the black POW/MIA banner. Other families of soldiers fighting overseas regularly appear wearing red, white and blue or sporting flags of various sizes.
Then there were the anti-war celelbrities such as Susan Sarandon and Martin Sheen. Sheen makes as much in one episode of the West Wing ($300,000) as Jessica Lynch's father makes in 10 years of driving a truck. If Karl Marx crawled out of his grave (and did not have his head shot off by my zombie hunting son), he'd be hard pressed to explain why the elder Lynch was more nationalistic and anti-communist than Martin Sheen even though Sheen is a member of the bourgeoisie and should defend the Capitalist system at all costs. Mrs. M finished up by saying that while she appreciates free speech and all, she wishes that people like Sheen who really didn't like the USA would just vote with their feet and leave - making room for those who do want to come here.
This is the rough equivalent of The Grateful Dead telling their fans to get a haircut and a job...
* * * *
I'm glad to see that NPR (Neverfails to Piss me off Radio) still maintains its bias against anything that smacks of American success in the war in Iraq. After all, nothing gets the blood flowing better in the morning than some poorly constructed journalism. This morning's Cumadin-moment occurred after a story about how US soldiers were greeted politely in Tikrit - but not with the bouquets of wildflowers that some had received in Baghdad (I doubt that the US Marines were crushed by this "flower-free" greeting in Saddam's hometown).
The next reporter then spoke about how Germany and France were concerned about being "locked-out" of the rebuilding of Iraq. One French business leader complained that France had been actively involved in the first Gulf War yet had not benefited from any of the contracts to rebuild Kuwait. The reporter then spoke about how Alcatel - the French telecoms firm - had rebuilt the Iraqi phone system after that war and was interested in rebuilding it again.
So where is the bias? First off, no effort was made by the reporter to provide an alternate viewpoint - for example, that France and Germany did not bury dead soldiers, actively sought to derail American efforts to contain the regime which in the end increased the likelihood of war and encouraged Iraqis to put up a fight that in turn lead to increased casualties on both sides. Secondly, the reporter failed to recognize and explore the connection between French/German insistance that the United Nations should rebuild Iraq and these contracts - even as the French spokesmen tap-danced around this issue. Finally, the reporter merely stated that France/Germany were "cool" to the idea of debt forgiveness for Iraq.
NPR is great for one reason though: no one listens to it. So if you feel like me and once supported your local public radio station, the next time they call to beg money tell them that you can't because of their support of NPR. Demand that they let the power of the marketplace into one of the last remaining vestiges of Communism in the USA.
|
BAGHDAD (AFP) - More than 100 children held in a prison celebrated their freedom as US marines rolled into northeast Baghdad amid chaotic scenes which saw civilians loot weapons from an army compound, a US officer said. Around 150 children spilled out of the jail after the gates were opened as a US military Humvee vehicle approached, Lieutenant Colonel Fred Padilla told an AFP correspondent travelling with the Marines 5th Regiment.
The children, who were wearing threadbare clothes and looked under-nourished, walked on the streets crossing their hands as if to mimic handcuffs, before giving the thumbs up sign and shouting their thanks. |
Unfortunately this may be missed by those non-embedded journalists whose ears are still ringing after the tank shell hit the Palestine Hotel in Baghdad. Not that Saddam's forces would have been using them as human shields or anything. They wouldn't stoop that low would they?
Five years in prison... Somebody needs to slap some sense into the above named "entertainers" and remind the journalists that the bar is temporarily closed at the Palestine..
Well we may or may not have found the "smoking gun": barrels of chemicals which may or may not be WMD. Some reports have them to be pesticide. Maybe I'm stupid (Mrs. Machiavelli says so), but has anyone read the complete label? Here's a translation of one of the labels a friend of mine, an "embed" with the 101st, passed along to me:
"RAID Republican Guard - New Extra Strength!
An outdoor product for use in backyards, patios, picnic areas and Kurdish villages. Sprays out far beyond ordinary infidel sprays -- actually kills Kurds up to 20 meters away. Kills and repels scorpions, special ops forces, mosquitoes, gnats, Kurds, Shi'a, Iranians and ants."
Ewww!
But seriously, as the Pentagon says, it is going to take serious time to find these things. We're going to have to test EVERYTHING EVERYWHERE. I doubt if Saddam labled and stored the things properly.
I discovered today that my site is representative of the neo-con movement at an anti-war site in Europe. In other words, they don't like it much - but they sure do hit it often enough. Yes The Razor is not anti-American - which makes it suspect in their view. It isn't even anti-European necessarily. What The Razor is anti-idiotarian.
The Razor is anti stupidity; that's the very essence of Occam's Razor. Cut through the crap and find the Truth. We will not stomach idiots - whether on the Left or even on the Right. Yes we have slammed Jimmy Carter (idiotarian extraordinaire). We have slammed the French for being idiots in too. But we also have slammed Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson. I'm sure we have slammed Pat Buchanan somewhere too. Idiocy has no political affiliation - though the vast majority of idiotic statements has been coming from the Left recently. Hence this journals tirades against them. Rest assured that when a Right Winger says something idiotic, we'll be there to call 'em on the carpet and swat their snouts with a rolled up newspaper...
But enough about idiots. Let's talk about heroes...
There's an Iraqi who is welcome to bring his family to the Machiavelli household for Korean barbecue any time. His name is "Mohammed" and his story can be found here. This guy risked his life to save an American all because he couldn't stand seeing a girl hit: "I saw them hit the female soldier, and my heart stopped." He risked his life walking a total of 18 miles through "Ambush Alley" to help get PFC Jessica Lynch out of the hands of the Fedayeen Saddam.
Imagine the courage this man had, the conviction - all because he couldn't stand a woman being slapped around. This guy stands for everything America is about: standing up for one's convictions, risking one's life to right an injustice, becoming involved when others prefer to look away.
Mohammed is a true hero and the kind of man we need more of in the world. He proves that even after 30 years, Saddam was unable to extinguish all vestiges of humanity and goodness from the land.
Colin Powell stated in Brussels that international organizations had a role in the rebuilding in Iraq - but when asked by a reporter to clarify that role Secretary Powell noted that the "Coalition of the Willing" "took a big hit - politically as well as in terms of treasure and lives lost".
As Den Beste notes here, the French don't have a word for chutzpah "because fish have no word for water." The very idea that the USA, Britain, Australia and the other nations who have risked increased terror attacks, economic embargo, political unrest - as well as lives of their servicemembers - would now hand over Iraq like a present to nations such as Belgium, Germany, France, China, Syria and Russia is simply one of the best political jokes I've heard since Al Sharpton announced his run for the presidency. Can we ever trust these nations in Iraq - or anywhere else - ever again? Is it possible that they will continue to work to undermine the liberation of Iraq in order to make the Coalition of the Willing look bad?
There should be a role for the UN to play: an empty symbolic role. That will allow the French to pretend that they still matter whereas they don't. It will also keep the UN too busy to focus their energy on undermining the rebuilding of Iraq. However any decision that matters must be made by those who risked everything in order to free the Iraqi people.
On another issue of note: A Shiite cleric issued a fatwa for Muslims to help the Coalition forces. A fatwa to help the infidel?
Oh, and for the liberals asking where were the Iraqis waving at our forces and welcoming us? Turn on Fox News...
One more thing about the French...
As a student of English and American history, one cannot help but have little respect for France and find them about as annoying as Cheryl Crowe. However, this crosses the line:

The story is here (from the BBC)
Here's how the French feel about the US, British, Canadian and Australian soldiers who snatched away their country from the Germans and handed it back to them - after paying the ultimate price...
"Dig up your garbage, it is fouling our soil." That's the translation for the shite on the left.
Jacque Chirac and de Villipin should personally apologize to the people of the UK and the USA for this sacriledge. Imagine the outcry here if some American youths spraypainted "French go home" on monuments in a French cemetery here. Oh, I forgot; there aren't any such cemeteries here...
Marines rock. What more can I say? Dad was in the Army, Wife is ex-Navy - as is Father-In-Law - but even they say that if you're in a "debate", there's nothing like a few Marines backing up your side of the argument. Marines have always been the 100% shit-kickers in the armed forces. If you need something done - against all odds and without excuses - you call in the Marines. That's why they were sent in to landlocked Afghanistan last year, and why they are driving up the Euphrates to clean out Baghdad now.
Mind you, I have the deepest respect for all the armed services and wouldn't discourage my kids from joining any one of them... But Oliver North is right: Marines simply are the best...
I'm still pissed at journalists as a whole. Of course I just finished Ann Coulter's book "Slander" which just might have something to do with it. I'll admit that I bought in to alot of the stuff she rails against, such as the Liberal's use of the term "Religious Right" as a straw man. If you haven't picked up this book, do so now. It's an easy read - well footnoted too just like Chomsky so you can impress your liberal friends.
Today was a good day. Our forces have pushed to the outskirts of Baghdad, three POWs were rescued, and two Iraqi divisions were smashed (note to future dictators: never EVER name military units after ancient Generals which you have zip in common with. Hammurabi was ahead of his time, but it says volumes when your code of justice is more brutal than his).
Of course Fox News is reporting that a Blackhawk has just gone down in Southern Iraq - killing 7. We must mourn their deaths properly, but not until the job is done.
Let's get 'em...
Deep Thoughts had gotten a bit too long and too dated, so we now introduce "Deeper Thoughts". To use a phrase from a dead language Bon Apetit...
So the allies have gotten "bogged down", and "resistance has proven stronger than expected". The Media is starting to dust-off the "Q" word to describe the war - against the Taliban in northern Afghanistan. Yes, we are hearing today the same tired echoes of the media from that last war.
As if anyone recalls, the Northern Alliance and allied forces swept towards Kabul, then apparently meeting that "unexpected resistance", "became bogged down" - apparently "ill-equipped to take the capital". So our troops waited around, caught up on their emails, showered, etc while air power ground the Taliban front-lines into dust. After the "lull" our forces were in Kabul before the ink was dry on several articles written by professional journalists describing the "Vietnamization" (ugly, ugly word) of the war against the Taliban. Too bad they were completely wrong.
So why do journalists persists in offering their opinions? Why can't they report an event without adding their analysis?
First, they are elitist and believe that their audience is unable to understand the news on their own. Journalists believe that they are part of the Fourth Estate - protectors of the public - yet by doing so they lose touch with the public which they claim to protect. Secondly, they believe that they know more about the event than others do and that it is their duty to impart this knowledge on their audience. If this includes their opinion, then so be it. Finally, it makes them part of the story. Instead of being mere voyeurs to an event, they become active participants. This is shown by Peter Arnett's taking credit for the anti-war movement in the USA. He no longer is a watcher - he is a player.
Professional journalists understand war about as well as Catholic priests (the ones NOT chasing after the altar boys) understand sex. They know how its done, and they see people do it - yet they really don't understand it. One is hard pressed to name a single professional journalist under the age of forty who served in the military. The vast majority of journalists have degrees in journalism, in contrast to the majority of Americans who don't have any type of college degree and if they do it isn't in journalism. Journalists are not required to study history the way that military officers are. Ask any military officer why the Battle of Cannae is important and you'll get a long-winded treatise. Ask a journalist and you'll get a blank stare.
Journalists are not military experts. They don't understand the history of warfare, its elementary tactics, or the possible outcomes as well as even teen-aged war-gamers do. Witnessing an event does not make one an expert in the same way that seeing black Americans doesn't make me an expert on African-American culture.
What America needs is a revamping of the way journalists are created. Reporters should go back to their role of reporting events, not participating in them. America also needs more amateur journalists or reporters with broader experience. That's where the internet comes in.
Steven Den Beste is not a professional journalist or pundit, but his essays are better researched and presented than anything currently in print. Glenn Reynolds' role of de facto "editor in chief" for blogdom, exposing writers from all corners of the web to the public, democratizes the media far better than the New York Times' hiring of a real conservative writer. Salam Pax has a sobering effect on both hawks and doves - more so than anything that appears in Time or Newsweek.
Blogs and online journals such as this one were born in the aftermath of September 11. That event energized people from all walks of life to take up the pen (or keyboard) and become journalists. Writer Harlan Ellison once wrote a short story called "I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream". For thousands of us, blogs and online journals are our mouths, and the blogosphere rings with the echoes of our screams.
Fuck you, Peter Arnett.
Deep Thoughts - What won't be happening over the next few hours
Rohrschach Test for the Left - Our first post. Written when Ground Zero was still a funeral pyre and the rest of America was speechless
Why Suicide Bombing Fails As A Strategy for Statehood - It appears that the Palestinians are finally learning this
Creators and Destroyers - A tribute to Daniel Pearl
When Saints Stumble- an open, so far unanswered, letter to Nelson Mandela
Your Conscience is Their Cover - Why Total War is the path to Peace
Bring it on al-Qaeda - America: Opening a giant-sized can of whoop-ass near you!

The Economist
Ha'aretz Daily
Jane's Information Service
Skeptical Inquirer
The Cato Institute
The National Review
![]()
|
![]()
Western Civilization and Democracy Net Ring |
|---|
| [Prev Site] [Stats] [Random] [Next 5 Sites] [List Sites] [Next Site] |
|
The Real Politically Incorrect Net Ring |
| [Prev Site] [Stats] [Random] [Next 5 Sites] [List Sites] [Next Site] |